A Sweet Surprise: 'Halloween Baking Championship' Stars Are Engaged

Fans of Food Network’s Halloween Baking Championship got an unexpected treat last week when longtime favorites John Henson and Stephanie Boswell revealed they are engaged. The announcement caught viewers off guard, as the pair had quietly kept their romance out of the spotlight — making the surprise all the sweeter for devoted followers of the hit series.

The happy news was shared via Instagram, where both stars posted joyful messages — and, of course, a close-up look at Boswell’s engagement ring. In her post, Boswell held her hand toward the camera to showcase the sparkling piece, captioning the image with her infectious enthusiasm: “YES YES A THOUSAND TIMES YES!!! WE’RE ENGAGED!!!” She added a playful note about bargain wedding dress shopping and dreams of a laid-back backyard celebration, complete with chickens — a glimpse into her warm, down-to-earth personality.

Henson echoed the excitement by sharing the same image on his own page, jokingly asking followers if anyone could recommend a good pastry chef for the wedding cake. He also left a heartfelt comment on Boswell’s post, writing that he has “never felt happier or more at peace,” calling himself “the luckiest man ever.”

Jewelry lovers were quick to zoom in on the ring, which appears to feature an elongated radiant-cut diamond at its center. The striking center stone is flanked by complementary radiant-cut side stones, forming a classic three-stone design set in a white metal — likely platinum or 18-karat white gold. The elongated shape gives the ring a graceful, finger-flattering presence, while the clean lines of the radiant cut deliver eye-catching brilliance.

Beyond its beauty, the three-stone engagement ring carries rich symbolism. Traditionally, the design represents a couple’s past, present, and future — with the side stones honoring shared memories and future dreams, and the center stone symbolizing the strength of the relationship today. It’s a meaningful choice for a couple whose love story has unfolded quietly behind the scenes before stepping into the spotlight.

Henson and Boswell’s connection began professionally on Halloween Baking Championship, where Henson serves as host and Boswell brings her expertise as a judge. Henson, a seasoned television personality and comedian, is also known for hosting Talk Soup and Wipeout, while Boswell has built an impressive culinary résumé with appearances on Next Baking Master: Paris and Spring Baking Championship. Their easy on-screen chemistry has long delighted fans — making their real-life partnership feel like a perfect match.

Credits: Photos via Instagram / realjohnhenson.